Judge Sotomayor has received
skepticism from liberal activists days after
President Barack Obama nominated her for
U.S. Supreme Court Justice. The skepticism toward
Sotomayor grew from her judicial records toward
abortion rights. According to the activists, there are numbers of court cases where
Sotomayor took stand against abortions. Hence, the activists are worried about whether the decision of
Roe vs Wade will be upheld or not.
In addition, the evidence of
Sotomayor's stance against abortion can be drawn from her criticism toward China enhancing forced abortion for
population control. Furthermore, the skepticism grew from her cultural background too since
Latinos are largest
anti-abortion group in Democratic Party.

However, some
Conservatives and
Republicans disagree with the activists since even the most radical
feminists can oppose forced
abortion. Also, the public needs to be aware about the possibility of her being "stealth judge", where
Judge Souter was one of them. Judge
Souter, who was appointed by the first
George W. Bush, believed to be Conservatives who opposed abortion. However,
Souter became a swing voter who upheld Roe vs Wade landmark decision. Hence,
Sotomayor might be in same category.
source:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/28/us/politics/28abortion.html?pagewanted=2&_r=1&hpw---------------------------------------------------------------
Comment by
Taka Laka:
I will admit, I thought
Sotomayor will not face any major opposition except from Republican Party, but I was wrong. I probably should have been skeptical toward
Sotomayor during
my first post about
Sotomayor's nomination after she said.
“our experiences as women and people of color affect our decisions.” -
Sotomayor“I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who
hasn’t lived that life.” -
SotomayorNow, just read
Sotomayor's quotes, there are possibility that she has her own bias towards some issue, especially the social issues like abortion and
gay marriage.
However, we also have to keep in mind that
Sotomayor is not campaigning for the
General Election.
Sotomayor was nominated to become Supreme Court Justice. For this reason,
Sotomayor might have been showing off her personality aside from her professional life as a judge. Also, I wouldn't be
surprised if
Sotomayor doesn't know any political strategy on what people can say on media.
For President Obama, like I said in
previous posts on
Sotomayor, I am certainly unsure on why he chose
Sotomayor as a nominee. If
Sotomayor is indeed, against abortion, there are high chance that some Senators from
Democratic Party will side with Republicans. Which means if
Sotomayor's nomination get blocked by the Senates, the vote will hurt the Democrats in the next election since they might lose
Latinos support. For this reason, again, I am not sure whether President Obama nominated
Sotomayor to gain support from
Latinos and make it historical, or he actually made a decision through series of interviews.